Sorry Nozbe (GTD Software Review)

I’ve been using Nozbe to manage my ToDo’s for about a year. It’s a good system, web-based, has an iPhone app that synchronizes pretty seamlessly, and has some powerful importing capabilities. It works, but for some reason I don’t love it. My subscription runs out in December, and I’m going to switch.

RelaxingOnBike

For background:

  • I try my best to implement GTD.
  • I lead an eight person marketing team in a company of about 50 people.
  • The marketing team uses Basecamp for large, multi-person projects.
  • I have been using Nozbe for personal projects and work projects that don’t involve others.
  • I use a PC at work, and until last week a PC at home. Now I use a Mac at home.

Nozbe is exclusively web-based. There’s nothing more convenient and cross-platform than keeping everything up in the cloud. You don’t have to worry about synchronizing data among computers. And, you can access your data from any machine–including ones that aren’t yours. That’s good. The downsides are that it’s slower than a desktop application and the development of some really powerful features is hampered by the web interface. Suggestion: Take a lesson from Evernote, and let me have the choice to use the cloud or the desktop.

Nozbe has a free iPhone app. The Nozbe iPhone app is very good, and it’s free. Thank you for not asking users to pay for an iPhone app on top of paying for the basic service.

The “+ New Action” button isn’t always visible. I find that when I’m adding lots of actions, moving actions between projects, and assigning contexts, the button disappears and I have to reload the page to get it back. In any ToDo program, the most important feature is to be able to add new action items anytime. Suggestion: Create a Facebook-like toolbar at the top or bottom of the page with key commands on it. You’ve got it on your iPhone app. Do the same thing on the site itself.

Nozbe supports multiple contexts. Nozbe contexts work like tags, and are pretty effective. The catch is that the number of projects and contexts you can use depends on the plan you purchase, and to really implement GTD, I find that I need to tag my stuff in lots of different ways. The limits aren’t too bad, because I can always purchase a bigger plan.

What’s most frustrating about contexts, however is editing them. Let’s say I have an action assigned to three contexts, and I want to delete two of them. I have to open the action for editing, delete one context, confirm my choice, then I have to open the action for editing again, delete the other context and confirm my choice again. My personal style is to be fairly liberal with tags as I enter items, and to clean them up once a week-during my weekly review. The way this works makes that process pretty frustrating. Suggestion: Let me delete and edit all the contexts and click save changes only once.

Nozbe has a powerful, flexible importing mechanism that is difficult to remember. Nozbe has developed a very powerful system for importing tasks from many different sources. You can upload a file, send an email, and even tweet your new action items and projects to Nozbe. The problem is that it requires that remember a fairly complex syntax to do all this. It’s powerful, but I can never remember all the rules. Suggestion: Send me back a confirmation when I add items letting me what you did with them, so I can fix it if I made a mistake. If I have to go to website to make sure I did it right, the importing feature looses it’s utility.

On the off chance that Michael (the Nozbe guy) reads this, I hope you find these comments and suggestions constructive.

Right now, I’m searching for a new system, and have been checking out

What do you use to keep yourself organized?

  • jupiter123

    Hello I red your post and i dont really understand why do you want to change of Nozbe. I never tried it anyway. I used Todledo and it ws convenient. But for many reason 2 years ago i decided to work on Omnifocus. For me it is a wonderfull software. Nothing is worth it. Things is really a toy and the hit list is not achieved. So OF is operation and believe me or not it is simple and efficient once you understand how it works. (More explaination on my blog) It sync with Iphone and works perfctly well with it except that the sync is sometime a little bit long.
    If you really want to use #GTD the best for me is paper. The choice after it may be #Omnifocus. I am also on twitter so you can see how passionate i am about it. (Find 1Jupiter). I never tried RTM. In a general way i don(t like full web solution. You never know what happen with companies and if they deasappear you are really in trouble. Another problem is security. Google and all these software are great even Monkey GTD wich is a great wicky such as TRACKS but what's happen about your data ? Of course you can be hacked on your own computer but if your are a company you will be very carefull with datas on the net even i must admit that it is indeed convenient.
    Then Trust omnifocus, try it, read forums, see videos, ask professionnals you will see that it is wonderfull software one of the best indeed for Macintosh.
    Hope that's help.

  • http://johnkendrickonline.com/ John B. Kendrick

    You might want to give OmniFocus a go since you are using a Mac now. I switched from Nozbe about 9 months ago and it was a good decision. You can read about my experiences at http://johnkendrickonline.com

  • http://tech-informer.com/ Ron

    With regards to RememberTheMilk, you may want to reference the two following articles:

    http://blog.rememberthemilk.com/2008/05/guest-p…

    http://sheenonline.biz/2008/06/super-charge-rem…

    I used to use the former, but have now switched over to the second system.

  • http://tech-informer.com/ Ron

    With regards to RememberTheMilk, you may want to reference the two following articles:

    http://blog.rememberthemilk.com/2008/05/guest-p…

    http://sheenonline.biz/2008/06/super-charge-rem…

    I used to use the former, but have now switched over to the second system.

  • smudgechris

    I've been trying out Nirvana recently (Nirvanahq.com) and it's really really impressed me. As well as being pretty it seems to better drill down to the core principles that I ever found Nozbe did.

    Transferring from one system to another can be a pain though. I'm just about moved over, and I'm a serial GTD app jumper. Hopefully I can finally rest with Nirvana.

  • http://twitter.com/applicomhq Applicom

    Hi,

    Maybe have a look at Apollo as well: http://www.apollohq.com
    It’s project and contact management, with cases&deals, timers, and a great calendar.
    We worked really, really hard on its user interface.

    Thanks a lot!

    Merc.

  • Gareth Knight

    Hi Adam,

    How are you finding OmniFocus a year down the track?

    G

    • http://amasur.me amasur

      I still like OmniFocus, and use it every day. I admit being a little disappointed that they charge for iPhone, iPad and Mac independently, but I’m past that now. Anything specific you’d like to know?

  • burbol

    I’ve been using Rememberthemilk. I am changing to nozbe. The google calendar implementation at RTM is awfull and you have to manage a lot of endlessly long list. Its a very overwhelming interface.